A simple TCP spoofing attack Over the past few years TCP sequence number prediction attacks have become a real threat against unprotected networks, taking advantage of the inherent trust relationships present in many network installations. TCP sequence number prediction attacks have most commonly been implemented by opening a series of connections to the target host, and attempting to predict the sequence number which will be used next. Many operating systems have therefore attempted to solve this problem by implementing a method of generating sequence numbers in unpredictable fashions. This method does not solve the problem. This advisory introduces an alternative method of obtaining the initial sequence number from some common trusted services. The attack presented here does not require the attacker to open multiple connections, or flood a port on the trusted host to complete the attack. The only requirement is that source routed packets can be injected into the target network with fake source addresses. This advisory assumes that the reader already has an understanding of how TCP sequence number prediction attacks are implemented. The impact of this advisory is greatly diminished due to the large number of organizations which block source routed packets and packets with addresses inside of their networks. Therefore we present the information as more of a 'heads up' message for the technically inclined, and to re-iterate that the randomization of TCP sequence numbers is not an effective solution against this attack. Technical Details ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ The problem occurs when particular network daemons accept connections with source routing enabled, and proceed to disable any source routing options on the connection. The connection is allowed to continue, however the reverse route is no longer used. An example attack can launched against the in.rshd daemon, which on most systems will retrieve the socket options via getsockopt() and then turn off any dangerous options via setsockopt(). An example attack follows. Host A is the trusted host Host B is the target host Host C is the attacker Host C initiates a source routed connection to in.rshd on host B, pretending to be host A. Host C spoofing Host A --> Host B in.rshd Host B receives the initial SYN packet, creates a new PCB (protocol control block) and associates the route with the PCB. Host B responds, using the reverse route, sending back a SYN/ACK with the sequence number. Host C spoofing Host A Host C responds, still spoofing host A, acknowledging the sequence number. Source routing options are not required on this packet. Host C spoofing Host A --> Host B in.rshd We now have an established connection, the accept() call completes, and control is now passed to the in.rshd daemon. The daemon now does IP options checking and determines that we have initiated a source routed connection. The daemon now turns off this option, and any packets sent thereafter will be sent to the real host A, no longer using the reverse route which we have specified. Normally this would be safe, however the attacking host now knows what the next sequence number will be. Knowing this sequence number, we can now send a spoofed packet without the source routing options enabled, pretending to originate from Host A, and our command will be executed. In some conditions the flooding of a port on the real host A is required if larger ammounts of data are sent, to prevent the real host A from responding with an RST. This is not required in most cases when performing this attack against in.rshd due to the small ammount of data transmitted. It should be noted that the sequence number is obtained before accept() has returned and that this cannot be prevented without turning off source routing in the kernel. As a side note, we're very lucky that TCP only associates a source route with a PCB when the initial SYN is received. If it accepted and changed the ip options at any point during a connection, more exotic attacks may be possible. These could include hijacking connections across the internet without playing a man in the middle attack and being able to bypass IP options checking imposed by daemons using getsockopt(). Luckily *BSD based TCP/IP stacks will not do this, however it would be interesting to examine other implementations. Impact ~~~~~~ The impact of this attack is similar to the more complex TCP sequence number prediction attack, yet it involves fewer steps, and does not require us to 'guess' the sequence number. This allows an attacker to execute arbitrary commands as root, depending on the configuration of the target system. It is required that trust is present here, as an example, the use of .rhosts or hosts.equiv files. Solutions ~~~~~~~~~ The ideal solution to this problem is to have any services which rely on IP based authentication drop the connection completely when initially detecting that source routed options are present. Network administrators and users can take precautions to prevent users outside of their network from taking advantage of this problem. The solutions are hopefully already either implemented or being implemented. 1. Block any source routed connections into your networks 2. Block any packets with internal based address from entering your network. Network administrators should be aware that these attacks can easily be launched from behind filtering routers and firewalls. Internet service providers and corporations should ensure that internal users cannot launch the described attacks. The precautions suggested above should be implemented to protect internal networks. Example code to correctly process source routed packets is presented here as an example. Please let us know if there are any problems with it. This code has been tested on BSD based operating systems. u_char optbuf[BUFSIZ/3]; int optsize = sizeof(optbuf), ipproto, i; struct protoent *ip; if ((ip = getprotobyname("ip")) != NULL) ipproto = ip->p_proto; else ipproto = IPPROTO_IP; if (!getsockopt(0, ipproto, IP_OPTIONS, (char *)optbuf, &optsize) && optsize != 0) { for (i = 0; i < optsize; ) { u_char c = optbuf[i]; if (c == IPOPT_LSRR || c == IPOPT_SSRR) exit(1); if (c == IPOPT_EOL) break; i += (c == IPOPT_NOP) ? 1 : optbuf[i+1]; } } One critical concern is in the case where TCP wrappers are being used. If a user is relying on TCP wrappers, the above fix should be incorporated into fix_options.c. The problem being that TCP wrappers itself does not close the connection, however removes the options via setsockopt(). In this case when control is passed to in.rshd, it will never see any options present, and the connection will remain open (even if in.rshd has the above patch incorporated). An option to completely drop source routed connections will hopefully be provided in the next release of TCP wrappers. The other option is to undefine KILL_IP_OPTIONS, which appears to be undefined by default. This passes through IP options and allows the called daemon to handle them accordingly. Disabling Source Routing ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ We believe the following information to be accurate, however it is not guaranteed. --- Cisco To have the router discard any datagram containing an IP source route option issue the following command: no ip source-route This is a global configuration option. --- NetBSD Versions of NetBSD prior to 1.2 did not provide the capability for disabling source routing. Other versions ship with source routing ENABLED by default. We do not know of a way to prevent NetBSD from accepting source routed packets. NetBSD systems, however, can be configured to prevent the forwarding of packets when acting as a gateway. To determine whether forwarding of source routed packets is enabled, issue the following command: # sysctl net.inet.ip.forwarding # sysctl net.inet.ip.forwsrcrt The response will be either 0 or 1, 0 meaning off, and 1 meaning it is on. Forwarding of source routed packets can be turned off via: # sysctl -w net.inet.ip.forwsrcrt=0 Forwarding of all packets in general can turned off via: # sysctl -w net.inet.ip.forwarding=0 --- BSD/OS BSDI has made a patch availible for rshd, rlogind, tcpd and nfsd. This patch is availible at: ftp://ftp.bsdi.com/bsdi/patches/patches-2.1 OR via their patches email server The patch number is U210-037 (normal version) D210-037 (domestic version for sites running kerberized version) BSD/OS 2.1 has source routing disabled by default Previous versions ship with source routing ENABLED by default. As far as we know, BSD/OS cannot be configured to drop source routed packets destined for itself, however can be configured to prevent the forwarding of such packets when acting as a gateway. To determine whether forwarding of source routed packets is enabled, issue the following command: # sysctl net.inet.ip.forwarding # sysctl net.inet.ip.forwsrcrt The response will be either 0 or 1, 0 meaning off, and 1 meaning it is on. Forwarding of source routed packets can be turned off via: # sysctl -w net.inet.ip.forwsrcrt=0 Forwarding of all packets in general can turned off via: # sysctl -w net.inet.ip.forwarding=0 --- OpenBSD Ships with source routing turned off by default. To determine whether source routing is enabled, the following command can be issued: # sysctl net.inet.ip.sourceroute The response will be either 0 or 1, 0 meaning that source routing is off, and 1 meaning it is on. If source routing has been turned on, turn off via: # sysctl -w net.inet.ip.sourceroute=0 This will prevent OpenBSD from forwarding and accepting any source routed packets. --- FreeBSD Ships with source routing turned off by default. To determine whether source routing is enabled, the following command can be issued: # sysctl net.inet.ip.sourceroute The response will be either 0 or 1, 0 meaning that source routing is off, and 1 meaning it is on. If source routing has been turned on, turn off via: # sysctl -w net.inet.ip.sourceroute=0 --- Linux Linux by default has source routing disabled in the kernel. --- Solaris 2.x Ships with source routing enabled by default. Solaris 2.5.1 is one of the few commercial operating systems that does have unpredictable sequence numbers, which does not help in this attack. We know of no method to prevent Solaris from accepting source routed connections, however, Solaris systems acting as gateways can be prevented from forwarding any source routed packets via the following commands: # ndd -set /dev/ip ip_forward_src_routed 0 You can prevent forwarding of all packets via: # ndd -set /dev/ip ip_forwarding 0 These commands can be added to /etc/rc2.d/S69inet to take effect at bootup. --- SunOS 4.x We know of no method to prevent SunOS from accepting source routed connections, however a patch is availible to prevent SunOS systems from forwarding source routed packets. This patch is availible at: ftp://ftp.secnet.com/pub/patches/source-routing-patch.tar.gz To configure SunOS to prevent forwarding of all packets, the following command can be issued: # echo "ip_forwarding/w 0" | adb -k -w /vmunix /dev/mem # echo "ip_forwarding?w 0" | adb -k -w /vmunix /dev/mem The first command turns off packet forwarding in /dev/mem, the second in /vmunix. --- HP-UX HP-UX does not appear to have options for configuring an HP-UX system to prevent accepting or forwarding of source routed packets. HP-UX has IP forwarding turned on by default and should be turned off if acting as a firewall. To determine whether IP forwarding is currently on, the following command can be issued: # adb /hp-ux ipforwarding?X ipforwarding: ipforwarding: 1 # A response of 1 indicates IP forwarding is ON, 0 indicates off. HP-UX can be configured to prevent the forwarding of any packets via the following commands: # adb -w /hp-ux /dev/kmem ipforwarding/W 0 ipforwarding?W 0 ^D # --- AIX AIX cannot be configured to discard source routed packets destined for itself, however can be configured to prevent the forwarding of source routed packets. IP forwarding and forwarding of source routed packets specifically can be turned off under AIX via the following commands: To turn off forwarding of all packets: # /usr/sbin/no -o ipforwarding=0 To turn off forwarding of source routed packets: # /usr/sbin/no -o nonlocsrcroute=0 Note that these commands should be added to /etc/rc.net If shutting off source routing is not possible and you are still using services which rely on IP address authentication, they should be disabled immediately (in.rshd, in.rlogind). in.rlogind is safe if .rhosts and /etc/hosts.equiv are not used. Attributions ~~~~~~~~~~~~ Thanks to Niels Provos for providing the information and details of this attack. You can view his web site at http://www.physnet.uni-hamburg.de/provos Thanks to Theo de Raadt, the maintainer of OpenBSD for forwarding this information to us. More information on OpenBSD can be found at http://www.openbsd.org Thanks to Keith Bostic for discussion and a quick solution for BSD/OS. Thanks to Brad Powell for providing information for Solaris 2.x and SunOS 4.x operating systems. Thanks go to CERT and AUSCERT for recommendations in this advisory. You can contact the author of this advisory at oliver@secnet.com -----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK----- Version: 2.6.3ia mQCNAzJATn0AAAEEAJeGbZyoCw14fCoAMeBRKiZ3L6JMbd9f4BtwdtYTwD42/Uz1 A/4UiRJzRLGhARpt1J06NVQEKXQDbejxGIGzAGTcyqUCKH6yNAncqoep3+PKIQJd Kd23buvbk7yUgyVlqQHDDsW0zMKdlSO7rYByT6zsW0Rv5JmHJh/bLKAOe7p9AAUR tCVPbGl2ZXIgRnJpZWRyaWNocyA8b2xpdmVyQHNlY25ldC5jb20+iQCVAwUQMkBO fR/bLKAOe7p9AQEBOAQAkTXiBzf4a31cYYDFmiLWgXq0amQ2lsamdrQohIMEDXe8 45SoGwBzXHVh+gnXCQF2zLxaucKLG3SXPIg+nJWhFczX2Fo97HqdtFmx0Y5IyMgU qRgK/j8KyJRdVliM1IkX8rf3Bn+ha3xn0yrWlTZMF9nL7iVPBsmgyMOuXwZ7ZB8= =xq4f -----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK----- Copyright Notice ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ The contents of this advisory are Copyright (C) 1997 Secure Networks Inc, and may be distributed freely provided that no fee is charged for distribution, and that proper credit is given. You can find Secure Networks papers at ftp://ftp.secnet.com/pub/papers and advisories at ftp://ftp.secnet.com/advisories You can browse our web site at http://www.secnet.com You can subscribe to our security advisory mailing list by sending mail to majordomo@secnet.com with the line "subscribe sni-advisories"
